Skip to content

Practical Reason

Newspaper columns, arguments and ideas

Posted on May 21, 2021 by anthonybut

A less funny follow up: “Life among the Econ: fifty years on”, Thomas Palley, April 2021

Click to access PKWP2106_tvZ792r.pdf

Share this:

  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
Like Loading...

Related

Leave a comment Cancel reply

Post navigation

Previous PostPrevious Life Among the Econ
Next PostNext What is it like to be a health minister?

Links

About Anthony Butler, from his UCT webpage

Follow Practical Reason on WordPress.com
Deputy finance minister Ashor Sarupen address the Cape Town Press Club, 8 October 2025
Deputy finance minister Ashor Sarupen addresses the Cape Town Press Club, 8 October 2025
Prof Mosa Moshabela, UCT Vice-Chancellor, addresses the Cape Town Press Club, 6 March 2025
UCT Vice-Chancellor Prof Mosa Moshabela addresses the Cape Town Press Club, 6 March 2025
Western Cape Premier Alan Winde addresses the Cape Town Press Club, 13 August 2024.
Western Cape Premier Alan Winde about to address the Cape Town Press Club on 13 August 2024
ActionSA Chairman Michael Beaumont addresses the Cape Town Press Club on 22 May 2024
IFP leader Velenkosini Hlabisa addresses the Cape Town Press Club on 16 April 2024
Fionnuala Gilsenan, Irish Ambassador, addresses the Cape Town Press Club on the 25th anniversary of the signing of the Good Friday Agreement, Kelvin Grove, 11 April 2023
Herman Mashaba, President of ActionSA, addresses the Cape Town Press Club on SA's economic crisis, 25 May 2022, Kelvin Grove.
Launch of Ronnie Kasrils' new book, International Brigade Against Apartheid, Artscape Theatre, 27 April 2022
Progressive Business Forum's post-SONA breakfast, with ANC treasurer general Paul Mashatile and minister in the presidency Mondli Gungubele, 11 February 2022

Alex Sept 3 2019. The SA state.

Police in Alex. 3 Sept 2019

Wally Serote

I did this world great wrong
with my kindness of a dog
my heart like a dog’s tongue
licking too many hands, boots and bums even after they kicked my arse

voetsek voetsek
shit. I still wagged my tail
I ran away still looking back with eyes saying please

Wally Serote, Collected Poems, 1982

Kokstad

President Cyril Ramaphosa unveils a plaque during the official opening of the Home Affairs Office in Kokstad, KwaZulu Natal. Former minister Malusi Gigaba is opposite. 03/10/2018 Kopano Tlape GCIS

Bumble bees

Bad fashion day: flight of the overweight bumble bees

More fashion concerns

Gwede "Suits" Mantashe and Dr Blade Nzimande

Fashion crisis deepens

Mineral Resources and Energy Gwede Mantashe during the Africa Oil Week at the Cape Town International Convention Centre. Date: November 05, 2019. Picture: ESA ALEXANDER/SUNDAY TIMES

No comment

Marriages of convenience

The ANC president and his deputy

Launch of Cyril Ramaphosa 2008

Cyril Ramaphosa at the launch of my biography of him in January 2008 at the Linder Auditorium. Thabo Mbeki was no longer ANC president and Ramaphosa's future seemed brighter in consequence.

CR: 2019 edition Jacana

Auckland Park, Jacana. This edition includes analysis of Ramaphosa's rise to the ANC and state presidencies.

A DP having fun

Deputy President Cyril Ramaphosa on a Human Resource Development Council tour of Ekurhuleni West TVET College, Germiston Campus in Gauteng. How deputy presidents suffer. 06/11/2015.

Luthuli and Tambo

Chief Luthuli and Oliver Tambo at Johannesburg Station, May 1959. Alf Kumalo.

Gille de Vlieg

Protest. Johannesburg 1986. Gille de Vlieg.

Tshenuwani Farisani

I babysat you, but now you are baas.
 I washed your diapers, but now I must go to hell.
 I saved you from a pool, but you shoot my child.
 I love you to earn your hate. 
I hosted you and lost my home. 
I became a human being to you, now I am an animal. I trusted your God, and it stole my land.

Tshenuwani Farisani, In Transit. Grand Rapids, Michigan, Eerdmans Publishing, 1990.

CR: 2019 edition James Currey Oxford

UK edition, James Curry, UK, US, Europe.

Paul Grendon

ANC election campaign, Cape Town, 1994. Paul Grendon.

Chris Van Wyk

Beware of white ladies

in chemise dresses

and pretty sandals

that show their toes. Beware of these ladies when spring is here.

They have strange habits Of infesting our townships with seeds of:

geraniums pansies poppies carnations. They plant their seeds in our eroded slums cultivating charity in our eroded hearts making our slums look like floral Utopias. Beware!

Beware of seeds and plants.

They take up your oxygen

and they take up your time

and let you wait for blossoms

and let you pray for rain

and you forget about equality

and blooming liberation

Chris van Wyk, It Is Time to Go Home. Johannesburg, Ad Donker, 1979,

Contemporary South Africa 2017 3rd edition

Fully updated third edition intended for international readers.

Merkel

President Cyril Ramaphosa meets Chancellor Angela Merkel of the Federal Republic of Germany for bilateral talks ahead of the G20 Compact with Africa and G20 Investment Summit which take place tomorrow 30 October 2018, in Berlin.South Africa, with Germany Co-Chair the Advisory Group on the Compact with Africa that was initiated under Germany’s Presidency of the G20 in 2017.Germany and South Africa enjoy a robust and growing trade relationship.In 2017, Germany remained South Africa’s 3rd largest global trading partner.

Tshenuwani Farisani

You pushed me from the fat of the country to the homelands. You fed me a bogus independence.
 You made me a citizen of a banana republic. And made babies my rulers.
 You banned me from my country of birth, And called me citizen undetermined.

Tshenuwani Farisani, In Transit. Grand Rapids, Michigan, Eerdmans Publishing, 1990.

Gille de Vlieg

Gille de Vlieg. Forced removals, Cornfields, Natal, 1988.

Peter Magubane

May 1960. Sharpville Funeral. More than five thousand people were at the graveyard. Photograph: Peter Magubane.

Dennis Brutus

They are coming back

through woodsmoke weaving from fires and swirls of dust from erratic breezes you will see

ghosts are returning

ghosts of young men, young women young boys, young girls

students:

and if you look closely

you will see

many of them have torn flesh

have wounds bright with fresh blood and there is blood in the sands of Soweto

Dennis Brutus, ‘Remembering June 16, 1976’, in Remembering Soweto 1976. Elmwood, Canada, Whirlwind Books, 1992.

Teresa May

President Cyril Ramaphosa held a bilateral meeting with the UK Prime Minister Theresa May. President Ramaphosa is on a working visit to London, to attend the Commonwealth Heads of Government meeting scheduled to take place from the 19th - 20th April 2018. 17/04/2018; photo:Yandisa Monakali

CR: First edition 2007

Biography of Cyril Ramaphosa (Jacana 2007). Latest edition 2013.

#CR2017 and #NDZ2017

Unity in Action. Sweet.

GSDPP

GSDPP panel in Somerset West, August 2017

Ronnie Kasrils

Launch of The Idea of the ANC, The Book Lounge, Cape Town 2013. With Ronnie Kasrils.

Remaking the ANC

An edited collection on why and in what ways dominant parties change when they lose power. Jacana 2014. Very interesting chapters on Taiwan, Mexico, Malaysia, and others. My reflections on SA are perhaps less insightful. Suitable for all readers, but heavy going in places.

Idea of the ANC

Jacana 2012 and Ohio University Press 2013. A great book to write. There are some fresh ideas in here, and the photographs are spectacular. (Many of them are reproduced on this sidebar.) Written for the sophisticated general reader.

David Goldblatt

Voter education, farm outside Potchefstroom, 1994. David Goldblatt.

Paying for Politics

An edited collection about party funding. Great chapters on Mexico, Russia, Brazil, Malaysia, and elsewhere. Jacana 2012.

Democracy and Apartheid

My first book on SA, written two decades ago. A hard read, not suitable even for postgrad students, but some interesting ideas for scholars with a background in conceptual analysis and democratic theory. (Macmillan and St Martin's Press 1998.)

Transformative Politics

My first book. Very hard to follow now. Not a good idea for general readers or students, but some of it remains of interest, in the light of Brexit and the Euro crisis. Macmillan and St Martin's Press 1995.

Presidential guesthouse, 2014.

Presidential guesthouse, 2014.

Prayer meeting, Tums Hall 1976. David Goldblatt

Prayer meeting, Tums Hall 1976. David Goldblatt

CR with JM and WMM

80th Birthday party, 2016, Mount Nelson

Recent posts

  • Important ANC Statement on the Preparation of Christmas Lunch
  • The G20 revealed a shift in South Africa’s foreign policy
  • Ramaphosa is likely to see out his second full term as state president
  • Bifurcated political systems
  • Elections no longer secure democracy
  • Sarupen likely to take Zille’s position
  • A president and a PM, at home and abroad
  • A new iteration of BEE is possible
  • Trump may just be the beginning
  • SA’s human rights crisis
  • Beware the ageing strongmen that presidential systems bring
  • Why we don’t get the leaders we need
  • Time for leadership turnover in the DA?
  • Commissions of Inquiry Predictably Impede Prosecutions
  • The property rates dilemma
  • ANTHONY BUTLER: Golf is a convenient obsession for the global elite
  • Vulindlela Phase 2
  • Keep calm amid the dramas of coalition politics
  • Oh no, it’s Paul again
  • The limits of political biography
  • Toward a foreign policy based on the national interest
  • SA foreign policy in the time of Trump
  • Appointing American Ambassadors
  • Mantashe and Motsoaledi take the bullets for their boss
  • MK Party looks for a national footprint
  • ANC factional consolidation may be slow in 2025
  • Scrambled eggs with Zuma
  • Trump
  • Two political streams emerge
  • The second termer’s turn to legacy politics
  • Demonisation in decline in GNU?
  • Why the GNU is making Ramaphosa happy
  • Dizzying ambition at home affairs
  • Are the cults in decline?
  • Less bleating about cabinet bloating
  • The limitations of Gamson’s Law
  • Thinking long term about coalition government
  • A period of minority government might still be needed
  • The end of stability?
  • A path to GNU?
  • Time for a real party funding law
  • Last minute ANC rally may not materialise
  • The DA’s real challenge isn’t ANC lies
  • The ANC and the churches
  • President Mantashe anyone?
  • Zuma’s Arc
  • Generalissimo Lesufi
  • Countries that find coalitions difficult
  • Why manifestos matter
  • Two ANC election vulnerabilities
  • Countering electoral manipulation
  • What’s Suella Motsoaledi up to now?
  • Does it matter that Gcaleka worked for Malusi Gigaba?
  • Sport needs resources more than it needs platitudes
  • A disappointing premier
  • Madness or Method from Mantashe?
  • Another controversial intervention from Thabo Mbeki
  • The puzzle of weak opposition parties
  • Brics: Bricolage or Hodgepodge
  • Russia’s Moon Mission Falters
  • The resources, stupid!
  • Are Ramaphosa and Mantashe enemies or brothers? Some thoughts on the value of public photography
  • Emerging tensions between the BRICS big players
  • The many ways of hiding corruption
  • Just confused about just transition
  • Little progress on NHI
  • Holden’s take on Zondo
  • Gloomy sentiments
  • Closing in on a grid collapse
  • The unlikely rise of the Gauteng ANC
  • SA’s foreign policy dilemmas
  • The crisis in SA’s schools
  • SA’s hopeful revolutionaries
  • A new deputy president for 2024?
  • Watch out for vote rigging
  • The talents of Fikile Mbalula
  • The ANC’s electoral prospects in 2024
  • Time for a reform-oriented energy minister
  • Mashatile, Mkhize and Ramaphosa
  • Is a Mashatile presidency on the cards?
  • Political deployment cycles and SOE bailouts
  • Not all slates are the same
  • Slates are not dead
  • Kings, Queens and Presidents
  • What kind of ANC collective leadership does Ramaphosa want?
  • Thabo Mbeki’s mixed legacy
  • Time to ditch the lump of labour fallacy
  • How “independents” bolster existing parties
  • The Commonwealth may still matter to SA
  • Judges and electoral systems
  • Blackout
  • Beleaguered presidents
  • The politics of time
  • Did Mandela want Ramaphosa to be his successor?
  • Thoko Didiza and the locusts
  • The strengths of democracy
  • The trouble with social compacts
  • Foreign policy after Ukraine
  • Crises close in
  • Ukraine
  • It’s the SOEs, stupid
  • The future of SOEs
  • Lindiwe Sisulu’s presidential bid
  • We still need Santa
  • Economic diplomacy rules
  • Will the ANC finally lose in 2024
  • Method in Mantashe’s madness
  • Reasons for mandate hesitancy
  • Rating Ramaphosa
  • More problems with BIG
  • Mantashe’s reminder about ANC clientelism
  • The problem with symbolic policies
  • We need more trust and better communications for vaccine rollout success
  • Enough conspiracy theories
  • What kind of state are we in?
  • Flattery, fawning and brown-nosing from the SACP
  • The politics of vaccine rationing
  • A growing centralisation of power
  • What is it like to be a health minister?
  • A less funny follow up: “Life among the Econ: fifty years on”, Thomas Palley, April 2021
  • Life Among the Econ
  • Managing joint programmes for public service reform
  • Why Magashule’s departure matters
  • Averting the demise of the public domain
  • Ramaphosa’s public sector reform project
  • Time to end cadre deployment
  • Unshackle Gauteng and the Western Cape so that they can grow
  • Getting off the ground
  • Mantashe is in the wrong job
  • Burdens of academic leadership
  • Who runs the DA? And how will it form coalitions?
  • Stop smoking your Rooibos
  • Perils of the District Development Model
  • Will local, national and provincial elections be merged?
  • Santa Cyril’s year
  • The Troubles of National Treasury
  • Conspiracy theories
  • Losing his Mojo or just losing his mind?
  • Paul Mashatile’s presidential ambitions
  • Time for a Cabinet reshuffle
  • Keeping the president healthy
  • Mashaba’s ActionSA and the DA are natural coalition partners
  • Ramaphosa’s empty letter to ANC cadres
  • Blaming Ace Magashule
  • A full IMF bailout before the 2024 elections?
  • Basic income grant rises from the political grave
  • Politics of blame will scupper Mboweni reforms
  • Judicial dreamers
  • Thinking about constitutional crises
  • ANC Economic Transformation Committee’s draft paper on post-Covid Economic Reconstruction, 22 May 2020

Categories

  • Uncategorized
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • GitHub
  • WordPress.com
Blog at WordPress.com.
  • Comment
  • Reblog
  • Subscribe Subscribed
    • Practical Reason
    • Join 37 other subscribers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Practical Reason
    • Subscribe Subscribed
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Copy shortlink
    • Report this content
    • View post in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...
 

You must be logged in to post a comment.

    %d