ANTHONY BUTLER: At best, cadre deployment was a transitional instrument whose time has passed
It might be a good idea in principle but it has been a disaster in practice
First published in BL PREMIUM
29 APRIL 2021
President Cyril Ramaphosa was unfortunately ambivalent about cadre deployment at his appearance before theĀ Zondo commission of inquiry this week. He argued that deploymentĀ ācannot be faulted in principleā, while conceding that there are āweaknesses in its practical implementationā.
He is surely right that politicisation is unavoidable and in respects desirable. Public servants cannot help but bring values, intellectual assumptions and personal networks to their roles. In addition, a democratic system requires a public service that is responsive to the policy preferences of a properly elected government.
If cadre deployment is a good idea in principle, however, there is no escaping that it has been a disaster in practice. Drawing selectively on the findings of an Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development study, Ramaphosa ignored conclusive evidence from the same body that unchecked conflicts of interest, and a lack of transparency in appointments, deeply damage the operations of the state.
Public service & administration minister Senzo Mchunu this week told a conference of the government and public policy think-tank that public perceptions of incompetence, poor productivity, lethargy and unprofessional conduct are ānot wrongā. More than a third of civil servants occupy positions they are demonstrably not qualified for.
Meanwhile, the boards of state-owned enterprises (SOEs) and government agencies have been stuffed with an array of disreputable deployees, from Brian Molefe to Dudu Myeni and Arthur Fraser. Ramaphosa conceded to the commission of inquiry that disastrous appointments have been made, but he suggested this was not a result of the deployment process. In fact responsibility lies with Jacob Zuma, who purportedly circumvented the deployment committee of which Ramaphosa was the chair.
There is surely a deeper problem with deployment that needs to be confronted honestly. The policy was always designed to do more than help overhaul the apartheid state. Underlying it was a pseudo-Marxist assumption that a ācapitalist stateā is predisposed to service the interests of the owners of capital. It is therefore a hostile terrain that must be occupied, an instrument whose ālevers of powerā must be āseizedā.
The ANC also belittled the institutions of ābourgeois democracyā ā parliament, the media, civil society organisations and mechanisms of intrastate accountability ā that are in fact essential if corruption is to be contained. The ANCās ambivalence about stable protections for public service impartiality created space for cycles to build up between deployment, access to state resources and donations to the party or its factions.
Meanwhile, a party fundraiser, Valli Moosa, was deployed in the mid-2000s to chair Eskom, at exactly the moment an ANC-aligned investment vehicle, Chancellor House, secured enormous remunerative contracts from the parastatal. This helped make legitimate what soon became a systematic looting of SOEs.
Money flows and deployments have become systemically linked, and donations have become de facto kickbacks. This system has matured, and its reach has extended beyond tender and audit committees to embrace external auditors and intrastate accountability mechanisms.
Surely it is time for deployment to be retired as a philosophy and as a practice. At best, it was a transitional instrument whose rationale and time have passed. Ramaphosaās position, however, is to hedge. He has promised to establish an āSOE councilā, which will supposedly improve governance and oversee appointment processes.
The Public Service Commission (PSC) will be empowered to play a new role in the appointment of senior national and provincial officials. There is also talk of a new head of the public service to oversee bureaucratsā career progression in a āprofessionalisedā state.
This raises one obvious question: how can we be sure the new parastatal council, the enhanced PSC, and the fresh civil service head, will perform their roles in a principled way? Donāt worry, is Ramaphosaās answer. The deployment committee will see to it that in all three cases the best people for the job will be appointed.
⢠Butler teaches public policy at the University of Cape Town.